---
title: Why modelled industry jobs can differ from local knowledge
description: Why modelled industry jobs in Economic Profile can differ from what local businesses report, and how to read modelled estimates for small economies.
---

[Skip to content](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/why-modelled-industry-jobs-can-differ-from-local-knowledge#main-content)

![ID-logo-colour\_version\_2.png\]](https://answers.id.com.au/hs-fs/file-2628100188-png/images/ID-logo-colour_version_2.png?height=40&name=ID-logo-colour_version_2.png)

Open main navigation

Close main navigation

- [Search Places](https://www.id.com.au/places/)

[Search Places](https://www.id.com.au/places/)

 Let's find you an answer.

- There are no suggestions because the search field is empty.

1. [Help Centre](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers?hsLang=en)
2. [Economic Profile](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/economic-profile?hsLang=en)
3. [Data & Methodology](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/economic-profile?hsLang=en#data-methodology)

# Why modelled industry jobs can differ from local knowledge

## Modelled estimates and on-the-ground observation measure different things, and what councils see locally can improve the next release

Modelled industry jobs are annual estimates for the whole LGA, built from multiple data, including taxation, survey and Census data. What local businesses report is immediate, specific and often ahead of the data. When the two disagree, it is rarely a case of one being wrong - they are measuring different things on different timeframes, and the disagreement itself is useful information that can feed the next release.

### What the modelled estimates can and cannot capture

#### What they capture

The employment estimates are built on various data, which are more timely and accurate than Census income responses, benchmarked to the Census and updated between Censuses using the Labour Force Survey, taxation and administrative data. The definition is total jobs, including full and part time and averaged across the financial year (hence remove seasonal fluctuations). The estimates also correct for the Census undercount of workplaces - the Census cannot place every worker at a workplace, so modelled local jobs sit above raw Census place-of-work counts, with the biggest adjustments in industries such as construction where many workers have no fixed workplace.

#### What they cannot capture

Three honest caveats apply whenever modelled figures are compared with local observation:

- **The data is backward looking.** The most recent year in the series ended some time ago, and conditions may well have moved since. A change businesses are living through now will not be in the current figures.
- **The figures are averages over the financial year, not a point-in-time snapshot.** A business that closed in May still shows up as most of a year of activity in that year's data.
- **One or two businesses will rarely move an LGA total.** A closure that dominates conversation in a town can be genuinely invisible in an LGA-level figure, even when it is locally significant.

### Local knowledge is an input, not a complaint

'That is not what local businesses tell us' is not a complaint to be managed - it is an input, and the model is designed to take it. Where a council tells .id about a plant closure, a major development or a specific employer decision, that information is substituted for the model-based estimate. .id also formally surveys councils as part of the annual quality assurance process, asking whether they have observed business closures or major employment losses in the reference year and whether anything else is relevant, such as recent performance or upcoming major projects.

The most useful report is a specific one: the business, the industry, the approximate number of jobs and the timing. That detail goes into the quality assurance of the next release.

### Frequently asked questions

**Q: The modelled jobs for an industry don't match what local businesses tell us. Which is wrong?**

A: Often neither. The modelled figure is a financial-year average for the whole LGA, built from data that lags current conditions, while local reports are immediate and specific. Check the timeframes first, then tell .id what you are seeing - with the business, industry, approximate jobs and timing - so it can be reflected in the next release.

**Q: A major local employer closed. Why hasn't the data moved?**

A: Two reasons are common. The closure may fall after the most recent data year, so it is not yet in the series at all. And because the figures are financial-year averages, a business that closed partway through a year still contributes most of a year of activity to that year's data. The full effect appears in later releases.

**Q: How do we get local events reflected in the data?**

A: Report them to .id with as much specificity as you can - the business, the industry, the approximate number of jobs and the timing. Documented local knowledge of closures, major developments and employer decisions is substituted for model-based estimates, and councils are formally asked for this information in the annual quality assurance process.

**Q: The model shows growth in an industry we know is struggling. Can we trust it?**

A: Treat a movement that contradicts strong local knowledge as a data question rather than an economic finding until it has been checked. Industry-level estimates are more volatile between releases than LGA totals, and the most recent years are the most likely to be revised. Raise it with .id - it may be a genuine pattern the local view is missing, or it may be something the next release's quality assurance should look at.

### Related articles

- [How the NIEIR economic model works](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/how-the-nieir-economic-model-works?hsLang=en)
- [Why economic figures change between annual releases](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/why-economic-figures-change-between-annual-releases?hsLang=en)

- [General](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/general?hsLang=en)
- [Placemaker](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/placemaker?hsLang=en#main-content)

    - [Getting Started](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/placemaker?hsLang=en#getting-started)
    - [Using the Product](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/placemaker?hsLang=en#using-the-product)
    - [Data & Methodology](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/placemaker?hsLang=en#data-methodology)
    - [Account & Access](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/placemaker?hsLang=en#account-access)
    - [Release Notes](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/placemaker?hsLang=en#release-notes)
- [Local Government suite](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/local-government-suite?hsLang=en#main-content)

    - [Getting Started](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/local-government-suite?hsLang=en#getting-started)
    - [Using the Products](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/local-government-suite?hsLang=en#using-the-products)
    - [Account & Access](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/local-government-suite?hsLang=en#account-access)
    - [Release Notes](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/local-government-suite?hsLang=en#release-notes)
    - [Data & Methodology](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/local-government-suite?hsLang=en#data-methodology)
- [Community Profile](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/community-profile?hsLang=en#main-content)

    - [Account & Access](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/community-profile?hsLang=en#account-access)
    - [Data & Methodology](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/community-profile?hsLang=en#data-methodology)
- [Social Atlas](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/social-atlas?hsLang=en#main-content)

    - [Account & Access](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/social-atlas?hsLang=en#account-access)
    - [Data & Methodology](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/social-atlas?hsLang=en#data-methodology)
- [Population Forecast](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/population-forecast?hsLang=en#main-content)

    - [Account & Access](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/population-forecast?hsLang=en#account-access)
    - [Data & Methodology](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/population-forecast?hsLang=en#data-methodology)
- [Economic Profile](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/economic-profile?hsLang=en#main-content)

    - [Using the Product](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/economic-profile?hsLang=en#using-the-product)
    - [Data & Methodology](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/economic-profile?hsLang=en#data-methodology)
    - [Account & Access](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/economic-profile?hsLang=en#account-access)
- [Housing Monitor](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/housing-monitor?hsLang=en#main-content)

    - [Account & Access](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/housing-monitor?hsLang=en#account-access)
    - [Getting Started](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/housing-monitor?hsLang=en#getting-started)
    - [Data & Methodology](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/housing-monitor?hsLang=en#data-methodology)
    - [Using the Product](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/housing-monitor?hsLang=en#using-the-product)
- [Community Views](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/community-views?hsLang=en#main-content)

    - [Account & Access](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/community-views?hsLang=en#account-access)
    - [Using the Product](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/community-views?hsLang=en#using-the-product)
    - [Data & Methodology](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/community-views?hsLang=en#data-methodology)
    - [Getting Started](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/community-views?hsLang=en#getting-started)
- [FAQs](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers/faqs?hsLang=en)

- Government Tools 
    - [Community Profile](https://www.id.com.au/solutions/gov-tools/community-profile/)
    - [Social Atlas](https://www.id.com.au/solutions/gov-tools/social-atlas/)
    - [Population Forecast](https://www.id.com.au/solutions/gov-tools/population-forecast/)
    - [Economic Profile](https://www.id.com.au/solutions/gov-tools/economic-profile/)
    - [Housing Monitor](https://www.id.com.au/solutions/gov-tools/housing-monitor/)
    - [Community Views](https://www.id.com.au/solutions/gov-tools/community-views/)
    - [Government Tools Overview](https://www.id.com.au/solutions/gov-tools/)
- Business 
    - [Demand Analytics Data & Services](https://www.id.com.au/solutions/demand-analytics/)
    - [Hotspot Report](https://www.id.com.au/solutions/hotspot-report/)
    - [Catchment Report](https://www.id.com.au/solutions/catchment-report/)
- Consulting 
    - [Consulting](https://www.id.com.au/solutions/consulting/)
- Support 
    - [Product Updates](https://www.id.com.au/product-updates/)
    - [Support / Knowledge Base](https://answers.id.com.au/en/answers)
    - [How Tos](https://www.id.com.au/insights/articles/categories/how-to/)
- Industries 
    - [Local Government](https://www.id.com.au/industries/local-government/)
    - [Education & Early Learning](https://www.id.com.au/industries/education/)
    - [Emergency Services](https://www.id.com.au/industries/emergency-services/)
    - [Utilities](https://www.id.com.au/industries/utilities/)
    - [Property & Retail](https://www.id.com.au/industries/property-retail-real-estate-services/)
    - [Financial Services](https://www.id.com.au/industries/financial-services/)
- Case Studies 
    - [Case Studies](https://www.id.com.au/case-studies/)
- Expertise 
    - [How We Help](https://www.id.com.au/how-we-help/)
    - [Our Datasets](https://www.id.com.au/our-data/)
    - [National Forecasting Program](https://www.id.com.au/forecast-review/)
- Insights 
    - [All Insights](https://www.id.com.au/insights/)
    - [Reports](https://www.id.com.au/insights/reports/)
    - [Webinars](https://www.id.com.au/webinars/)
    - [How Tos](https://www.id.com.au/insights/articles/categories/how-to/)
- About Us 
    - [About Us](https://www.id.com.au/about-us/)
    - [Team](https://www.id.com.au/our-team/)
    - [Careers](https://www.id.com.au/careers/)
    - [Referencing .id as a source](https://www.id.com.au/about-us/referencing-and-sources/)
    - [Contact Us](https://www.id.com.au/contact-us/)

[![.id - the population experts](https://answers.id.com.au/hs-fs/file-2628100188-png/images/ID-logo-colour_version_2.png?width=200&height=69&name=ID-logo-colour_version_2.png ".id - the population experts")](https://home.id.com.au?hsLang=en)

Informed Decisions Help Centre

 

Copyright © 2026, .id (informed decisions)